> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://hoeijmakers.net/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Innovation needs hands as well as heads
- URL: https://hoeijmakers.net/innovation-needs-hands-as-well-as-heads/
- Published: 2026-11-17T18:42:21.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T18:42:21.000Z
- Description: A WorldSkills clip, a conversation about quantum computing and Switzerland's innovation record raised a question: do we underestimate the practical skills that turn research into innovation?
- Author: Rob Hoeijmakers
- Tags: Innovation, Education, R&D

I have been trying to connect a few things that were already moving around in my head.

One is my interest in the difference between R&D and innovation. I wrote about that recently because the distinction matters more than I had realised. R&D is concerned with generating new knowledge and developing applications for it. Innovation is about putting something new or significantly improved into use.

Another was a conversation I had about quantum computing and education. We talked about the people a future quantum industry would actually need. Not only physicists and researchers, but also people capable of building, maintaining and improving the machinery around it.

Then I saw a short [Instagram clip](https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dd11CZqnCA3/?dlrf=MXF5MmNxdHdyanhvMA==) about the Berufs-WM, the WorldSkills competition, where young Swiss professionals compete internationally.

It stayed with me. There was something powerful in seeing young people who were clearly proud of being very good at something difficult and practical.

A little later I came across WIPO's Global Innovation Index. Switzerland was number one again.

That was when these things started to connect.

## R&D is not innovation

The OECD treats research and development and innovation as separate things.

Its [Frascati Manual](https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/frascati-manual-2015%5F9789264239012-en.html) describes R&D as systematic work aimed at increasing knowledge and finding new applications for it. The [Oslo Manual](https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oslo-manual-2018%5F9789264304604-en.html) distinguishes innovation by implementation: a new or significantly improved product has been made available, or a process has actually been brought into use.

That sounds simple, but it changes the picture.

A laboratory can produce knowledge. A prototype can demonstrate that something is possible. But between that and something that works in everyday life, a great deal still has to happen.

## The people in between

We tend to picture innovation through a few visible roles: the scientist, the engineer, the entrepreneur, the investor.

But someone also has to build the machine.

Someone has to manufacture the parts, install the equipment, calibrate it, troubleshoot it and keep it running.

This came up clearly in my conversation about quantum computing. A functioning quantum computer is not only physics and mathematics. It is also precision engineering, electronics, cooling systems and instrumentation.

A future quantum industry therefore does not only need quantum scientists.

It needs people who can build quantum machines.

The same applies to semiconductor equipment, photonics, robotics and medical technology. Once research starts moving into the physical world, theoretical knowledge alone is no longer enough.

And practical knowledge does not only become relevant after the research. It can shape the research itself.

💡

****Two ways of learning to innovate**  
In a [2007 paper](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2007.01.006?utm%5Fsource=chatgpt.com), Morten Berg Jensen and colleagues distinguished two complementary modes of innovation: ****Science, Technology and Innovation (STI)**, based on formal scientific and technical knowledge, and ****Doing, Using and Interacting (DUI)**, based on practical experience and learning with others. Studying Danish firms, they found that those combining both approaches were more likely to introduce new products or services than firms relying predominantly on one.

## Switzerland

This is why Switzerland became interesting to me.

[WIPO ranks Switzerland](https://www.wipo.int/en/web/global-innovation-index/2026/index) as the world's most innovative economy in 2026, for the sixteenth consecutive year. But the Global Innovation Index is not simply an R&D ranking. It looks at a much wider system: education, research, infrastructure, markets, business capabilities, knowledge exchange and innovation outputs.

Switzerland has world-class research, strong universities and major pharmaceutical, medtech and engineering industries.

But it also has a deeply rooted vocational education system.

That does not mean Switzerland's vocational education system explains its innovation ranking. Nor is practical training a substitute for research. But it made me wonder whether we sometimes underestimate the skills that connect new knowledge to practical applications.

And perhaps that is where those young people at the Berufs-WM belong in the story.

## What happens after the research?

Medical technology makes this quite tangible.

A new device may start with research, but it does not reach a hospital through research alone. It has to be engineered, manufactured, tested, installed and maintained. And the practical experience gained along the way can improve the next version.

All of that requires knowledge. Not all of it falls under R&D.

That may be the part I had underestimated.

When Europe talks about AI, quantum, semiconductors or advanced manufacturing, the discussion quickly moves to research budgets, startups, venture capital and regulation. Fair enough.

But eventually somebody has to build the thing.

And perhaps that is why that little WorldSkills clip stuck with me.